By James Brooks | JUNEAU, Alaska – The Alaska House of Representatives voted 22-18 late Sunday to ban transgender girls from girls’ school sports teams by limiting access to girls whose original birth certificates identify them as girls.

The decision followed hours of filibustering by a coalition of opponents, but supporters mustered enough votes to defeat dozens of amendments offered by those opponents and advanced House Bill 183 to the state Senate, where the proposal is expected to die without becoming law.

Though the Senate has said it will not hear the bill and there are no known transgender athletes in Alaska school sports, it was nonetheless a top priority for most of the House’s Republicans, who said they were responding to their constituents.

Rep. Jamie Allard, R-Anchorage, said she believes transgender girls are boys, and that the House Republicans were standing in support of other Alaskans who feel the same.

“I want you to know Alaska stands with you. I stand with you. I know my majority members stand with them too. To the parents of the children of Alaska, know we will fight. We will fight for your children. We will fight for your girls in sports,” she said.

Opponents of the bill said that if the proposal ever were to become law, it would immediately draw legal challenges for being discriminatory.

“Trans girls are girls. Our gender identity is determined in our brains, it is coded, it is fixed,” said Rep. Andrew Gray, D-Anchorage, who opposed the bill. “99.5% of us have a gender identity in our brains that matches our physical bodies, half a percent does not.”

Rep. CJ McCormick, D-Bethel, has suffered from a spinal condition since he was young. Speaking on the House floor, he said he was bullied and teased in school for being different. 

“I am a Bethel kid. I grew up in rural Alaska. I grew up with a rare spinal condition. Kids used to beat me up, just made fun of my neck,” he said.

He became friends with some of those bullies because of a shared love of sports, and he vehemently opposed the bill because it puts barriers in sports for children, he said.

“All of this debate is — we’re talking about kids! We’re talking about kids. We are attacking children!” he said.

Rep. Alyse Galvin, I-Anchorage, is the mother of a transgender daughter, and said she finds it hard to believe that Alaskans place this issue as a top priority. She said she believes “outside agitators” and social media have spun people up on the issue, but that can be overcome.

“I think we look within. We tune out the outside voices of hate, and discord. And we focus on our inside voice of love, empathy, compassion, understanding all the things that we were taught. The only way we are going to change the direction of the harmful discourse is to leave it from our hearts,” she said.

The final vote saw all 20 Republicans in the House’s majority caucus vote in favor of the bill, as did Reps. David Eastman, R-Wasilla, and Dan Ortiz, I-Ketchikan.

All of the House’s Democrats voted against the bill, as did all of its independents, with the exception of Ortiz. Rep. Louise Stutes, R-Kodiak and a minority-caucus member, was the lone Republican to vote against it.

After the bill’s passage, Rep. Zack Fields, D-Anchorage, requested a re-vote, which may take place Tuesday. The bill is still expected to pass on that re-vote, though the vote total may change.

******************************************************************************************

James Brooks is a longtime Alaska reporter, having previously worked at the Anchorage Daily News, Juneau Empire, Kodiak Mirror and Fairbanks Daily News-Miner. A graduate of Virginia Tech, he is married to Caitlyn Ellis, owns a house in Juneau and has a small sled dog named Barley. He can be contacted at [email protected].

******************************************************************************************

The preceding article was previously published by the Alaska Beacon and is republished with permission.

The Alaska Beacon is an independent, nonpartisan news organization focused on connecting Alaskans to their state government. Our journalists fairly and fearlessly report on the people and interests that determine state policy.

We’re part of States Newsroom, the nation’s largest state-focused nonprofit news organization.

By James Brooks | ANCHORAGE, AK. – Transgender girls in Alaska are now banned from competing on girls’ school sports teams.

The board of the Alaska School Activities Association — which regulates school sports in the state — voted 5-3 on Monday to adopt a new rule affecting transgender girls.

The rule was required by the Alaska state school board, which voted in August to require that ASAA create a sports division limited to students who are assigned female at birth. That excludes transgender girls.

More than half of U.S. states have some policy restricting the athletic participation of transgender students. Twenty-three states have limited transgender students by law, according to a count by the Movement Advancement Project, a nonprofit whose stated mission includes promoting equity and inclusion. 

Other states, including Alaska, have acted through regulation rather than law.

Members of the school board are appointed by Gov. Mike Dunleavy, and the new policy is one of several that his administration has proposed to limit the rights of transgender students.

A bill filed by the administration with the Alaska Legislature would require students to use bathrooms corresponding with their gender assigned at birth, and it would have required schools to inform parents if their child wants to use a different name or preferred pronoun.

Those proposals have since been revised and have yet to pass the Legislature in any form.

ASAA’s new rule takes effect 30 days after the board’s vote.

Under the new rule, a transgender girl is able to compete on a coed team or on a boys team, if a school has teams designated by gender.

The new ASAA rule is expected to draw legal challenges from civil rights organizations and could cause Alaska’s network of school sports to fracture.

Several school districts, including Anchorage, Alaska’s largest, have adopted anti-discrimination policies that conflict with ASAA’s new rule, and school districts across the state will be tasked with reconciling that conflict.

*****************************************************************************************

James Brooks is a longtime Alaska reporter, having previously worked at the Anchorage Daily News, Juneau Empire, Kodiak Mirror and Fairbanks Daily News-Miner. A graduate of Virginia Tech, he is married to Caitlyn Ellis, owns a house in Juneau and has a small sled dog named Barley. He can be contacted at [email protected].

The preceding article was previously published by the Alaska Beacon and is republished with permission.

The Alaska Beacon is an independent, nonpartisan news organization focused on connecting Alaskans to their state government. Our journalists fairly and fearlessly report on the people and interests that determine state policy.

JUNEAU, AK — After three failed attempts by conservative lawmakers to ban transgender female student-athletes from competing in school sports according to their gender identity, Alaska’s board of education voted 7-1 Thursday to approve a new regulation banning them from high school girls’ athletics. 

Following an hour of debate during a special meeting, every member of the Republican governor-appointed board of ed voted for the ban, except student representative Felix Myers, a high school student from Sitka, AK. As the Alaska Beacon reported, he was the lone voice against the regulation, and soundly rejected the arguments by those who said trans girls would join girls sports teams just to gain an unfair advantage. 

“I don’t think anyone would go through the strain, the bullying… all of the problems that come with being around kids when you’re different,” Myers said, who predicted the proposed policy could expose transgender students to more bullying. “If someone is truly going to go out of their way to identify this way, that is a huge sacrifice and they are the bravest, bravest students among us.”

Myers criticized the board for spending time on the policy rather than other issues facing the state’s education system.

“When it comes back to helping protect girls’ sports, I think there’s a lot more issues that we can address here in Alaska,” Myers said. 

Board member Lorri Van Diest introduced the first non-binding resolution related to the issue in March, and claimed it is impossible to balance inclusion with fairness because of the differences in physiology between males and females.

“I will be voting for the regulation amendment because I am part of the group which prioritizes competitive fairness and safety for high school girl athletes,” Diest said, giving a litany of examples of men’s athletic superiority over women.

Myers told Diest and the other board members they were mistakenly discussing the idea of men participating in women’s sports rather than the issue of trans women participating in women’s sports.

Currently, Myers said, this is not an issue in Alaska that the board needs to fix. The Alaska School Activities Association Inc. executive director Billy Strickland confirmed that a fairness issue with transgender students has not yet arisen.

Myers suggested the board consider educating coaches on how to identify eating disorders and the issue of funding parity for travel and equipment if it wants to support girls’ sports.

As the Anchorage Daily News reported, the ASAA, which oversees all high school activities in the state, is now empowered to implement the new regulation. Strickland said Thursday that the ASAA would most likely create two divisions in high school sports: one for girls presumed to be female at birth, and a separate one for all other students —including transgender students, boys, and girls who prefer to compete alongside boys.

The Matanuska-Susitna Borough School District is the only one in the state that has already adopted regulations restricting the rights of transgender kids from participating in school sports, according to the sex they were assigned at birth. 

Diest, Jeffrey Erickson, Sally Stockhausen, Pamela Dupras, Barbara Tyndall, Bob Griffin and James Fields were the members who voted in favor of the regulation, according to the Alaska Beacon. Myers and board member Lt. Col. James Fowley, who abstained, are considered advisory members. 

Sen. Löki Tobin (D-Anchorage) has repeatedly spoken against this new regulation. Tobin criticized the board for overstepping its authority because it moved to adopt these changes without any laws to support its decision.

“Removing all the artifice and double speak: any discrimination against a trans or non-binary child violates the foundation of what it means to be building a more perfect union,” she wrote in an email to the Beacon. “What we saw today is national politics, misinformation, and fear getting in the way of building a better future for all Alaskans. I find it appalling and a terribly sad day for the place I call home.”

Aaron Poe, the father of two high school students, one of whom is trans, said the decision is “profoundly disappointing.”

“The Department of Education that is supposed to be lifting all kids in Alaska up and supporting them and helping them be productive members of their society is essentially doing a backdoor deal to target trans kids,” he told the Beacon.

Poe is worried the new policy will discriminate against all girls who play sports, not just trans girls.

“What the policy change would do is focus on young women who maybe don’t appear or don’t act feminine enough, therefore making them a target of scrutiny,” he said, pointing to a case in Utah where a young woman’s sex was investigated by school officials after she excelled in sports. “The fact that people are willing to even take that up as an issue or a question, and imagine that school officials are going to police young women’s bodies, is just really disgusting.”

Alaska is now the 24th state to adopt a policy that restricts transgender athletes.